I can't recall how but a few years back I stumbled across an excerpt from the Hans Zimmer concert film Live in Prague (2017). It featured some of the most dramatic music from Christopher Nolan's Batman film, The Dark Knight, and was filmed like a rock concert in an arena, with multiple cameras and moody, dynamic lighting. Not long afterwards our whole household watched the concert in its entirety and enjoyed it immensely.
We've returned to it periodically and screened it for visitors a few times and everyone seems to have enjoyed it, and it has yet to become tiresome despite mupltiple vieweings. So when I learned that a new Hans Zimmer concert movie was being released to a handful of theatres, I was very grateful that Audrey and I were able to go to a Sunday matinee showing.
Hans Zimmer & Friends: Diamond in the Desert is as good a concert film as the Prague one (shot in the Dubai Coca Cola Arena), with three music video-style sequences shot in other venues including the desert and the top of the Burj Al Arab. The best part though are the interstitial discussions between Zimmer and a handful of associates: Chris Nolan, Denis Villeneuve, Pharrell Williams, Billie Eilish, Johnny Marr and more.
Shot in b&w and in a different aspect ratio, they are so casual and personal that I hesitate to call them interviews. These amazingly frank discussions about the challenges of the creative process, remaining motivated and what it took to get Zimmer on stage the first time ("bullying" by Pharrell Williams and Johnny Marr, according to him...) and why he finds himself spending so much time there all come across as honest and unforced.
I was afraid these would be a distraction from the music I had come to hear, but all of these insights enhanced the movie tremendously and entrenched my impressions of Zimmer as not only a brilliant film composer but also jsut a solid, gracious and frankly delightful human.
My favourite bits were Billie Eilish's producer brother Finneas asking if Zimmer cherry picks the best instruments to play when performing orchestral pieces live, and Johnny Marr (guitarist from The Smiths) marvelling at Zimmer's commitment to live touring, calling this charmingly awkward man a composer with the soul of a rock star.
At another point, Timothee Chalamet calls Zimmer (I believe) the greatest living composer, and it took me out of the film for a bit.
Like a lot of people my age, John Williams' soundtrack to the first Star Wars album (and the accompanying liner notes!) was my introduction to film scores, and from 12 years old I began paying attention to the credits and film scorers. In addition to his tremendous accolades, including 5 Oscars and an astonishing 54 (!) nominations to date, he has scored some of my favourite films of all time. I mean, just from memory I am thinking Superman, Close Encounters, Raiders, Jaws, and Harry Potter.
In terms of recognizable movie themes, he is likely to be unequalled in my lifetime, while very few of Zimmer's compositions have that innate catchiness or stick in one's memory the same way. But then I asked myself: beyond nostalgia, how many of Williams' pieces have the same emotional impact that Zimmer's does?
While the rest of Diamonds in the Desert played on (2:38 in total) I found myself catching my breath or dabbing my eyes at various points - of Williams' music, I think only the Schindler's List theme has had the same effect on me.
(I just played it to make sure, and yeah, there is definitely someone cutting onions somewhere in this house.)
The final piece of Zimmer's Gladiator suite ("Now We Are Free") chokes me up in way that has little connection to the bittersweet ending of that movie, and likewise for the intensely powerful "Time" that wraps up Inception. I don't have to think about my own late father to find "He Lives In You" from The Lion King: The Musical so emotionally resonant.
But thankfully there are other emotions to be triggered by Zimmer's repertoire: the building tension of Dunkirk, the fearful apprehension from The Dark Knight's "Why So Serious?", the adrenaline rush of Inception's "Mombasa" chase music.
And while I don't have a lot of time for Zack Snyder's take on my beloved DC superheroes, Tina Guo's blazing cello on Wonder Woman and Guthrie Govan's soaring electric guitar on Man of Steel are still exemplary compositions that clearly depict these legendary characters in my mind's eye as surely as George Perez or Curt Swan drawing them while simultaneously stirring my heart, and are even better live than on a studio recording.
If you are a fan of movies, music, movie music, the people who make movies and/or music or just creative staging and an exploration of the creative process, Diamond in the Desert is worth seeking out. Beyond even his music, Hans Zimmer is a gem beyond compare: warm, gracious, self-effacing and grateful.
Honestly, I think ranking musicians of composers like horses in a race is kind of a rube's game, should I hear anyone else describe him as the greatest living composer, I wouldn't be inclined to challenge them on it.